A compelling case for doing things differently.

Lynn Hendry Blog
Area: Dundee local area
Topic: Learning Communities Publications/links
Audience: Professionals

£1.2m invested. £13.28m in social and economic value. A compelling case for doing things differently.

Lynn Henry, Senior Executive, The Hunter foundation. 

An investment of approximately £1.2 million has generated an estimated £13.28 million in socio-economic benefit for Dundee over two years.

That finding should challenge how we invest public money, support communities and approach public service reform in Scotland.

BBC Children in Need and The Hunter Foundation have a long-standing partnership investing in community power and voice-led approaches to improve outcomes for children and families. Through What Matters to You (WM2U) in Dundee, we set out to test a clear proposition.  We knew that investing in community voice, local relationships and preventative support would improve lives, but could we also quantify the social and economic return to build a new argument for this type of investment.

An independent interim evaluation by Dartington Service Design Lab suggests we can.

Using a socio-economic model developed in line with HM Treasury Green Book guidance, Dartington estimates that WM2U generated £13,278,069 in socio-economic benefit for Dundee City across 2024 and 2025, following investment of around £1.2 million between 2023 and 2025.

This is more than a positive evaluation of a community programme. It is evidence that investing differently can create substantial value for individuals, society and the public purse.

For Scotland's public service reform agenda, the implications deserve serious attention.

Understanding the value of prevention

The estimated £13.28 million combines direct benefits for participants with wider benefits for Dundee.

Around £4.9 million relates to people directly participating in WM2U activities across the two years, including approximately £450,000 in benefits for under-16s. The remaining estimated £8.4 million represents wider benefits to Dundee's population, including people who have never directly participated.

That wider reach matters. It suggests that investing in community capacity, relationships and local leadership can create value far beyond those who first engage.

The model considers 18 socio-economic outcomes across employment, education, health, wellbeing and quality of life. It draws on local authority performance and outcome data, the wider WM2U evaluation, and national and academic research.

Behind these estimates are changes in people's lives. The evaluation captures improvements in wellbeing, confidence and personal development. People have become more willing and able to seek help with their health, improve family circumstances, manage finances and explore employment opportunities.

The impact also reaches into communities. People are volunteering, supporting neighbours, becoming community leaders and helping others access support. Community organisations are gaining confidence and influence, and relationships with public services are changing.

These are the foundations of prevention: helping people address challenges earlier, strengthen their resilience and contribute to the wellbeing of others.

The £13.28 million is estimated socio-economic value, not cash savings that can simply be removed from public service budgets. That distinction matters. The model makes visible benefits that traditional budgets and performance measures often overlook.

Why this matters for public service reform

Scotland has long talked about prevention and public service reform. Responding once problems are entrenched is costly, not just to public budgets, but to people's lives.

Yet our systems and budgets still favour responding to immediate demand over investing in the conditions that prevent it.

The WM2U findings challenge that balance.

If around £1.2 million can generate an estimated £13.28 million in socio-economic benefit, what could sustained investment in community-led prevention make possible? The findings make a strong case for testing that potential at greater scale.

This is not about simply moving money between services. It is about changing the relationship between public services and communities and investing in the conditions that support better outcomes.

WM2U has demonstrated the value of bringing people together around what matters locally, giving communities genuine influence over decisions and resources, and supporting practitioners to work alongside them.

Through the Make It Happen Fund, community conversations and stronger Local Community Planning Partnerships, people have moved beyond consultation to actively shaping decisions.

Communities are not simply service recipients or another delivery partner. They are essential infrastructure for prevention.

There can be no meaningful prevention strategy without empowered communities.

The challenge for government and funders

The economic evidence strengthens the case for changing how public resources are allocated.

Prevention exposes a weakness in how we fund public services: one organisation may invest, while benefits accrue elsewhere and over time. Individual budgets can therefore struggle to justify investment that creates wider public value.

We need to measure that value and fund accordingly. That means supporting collaboration, longer-term investment and community influence, rather than reinforcing short-term organisational priorities.

Government, local authorities, health services and independent funders all have a part to play. As funders, we must examine our own practice too. We cannot call for greater community power while keeping control of every decision and resource.

WM2U is not a blueprint to copy, every community is different. But its principles are transferable - start with people, invest in relationships, build local capacity, share power and measure the wider value created.

This is an interim evaluation, deliberately cautious, with a final report due in early 2027. It is not the last word. But it is a compelling reason to act on the potential of community-led prevention.

We know the cost of failing to prevent problems. These findings show the potential value of doing things differently.

The estimated £13.28 million is more than a headline. It strengthens the economic case for making community voice, agency and prevention central to Scotland's public service reform agenda.

The challenge is to turn that evidence into investment decisions: funding earlier support, sharing power and measuring success beyond individual service budgets.

If Scotland is serious about reform, prevention cannot remain an ambition that loses out whenever immediate pressures mount.

We need to invest earlier and differently recognising communities as partners in creating social and economic value.

Prevention is not something public services can deliver to communities. It is something we must build with them.

The WM2U team will host a free national event on Tuesday 9 March 2027 at The Barracks, Stirling, to launch the final report and bring together people ready to take this agenda forward.